Authorities have launched a murder investigation after the body of 16-year-old Indigenous girl, Challistia Colelay, was discovered on November 3, 2025, in Whiteriver, Arizona, on Fort Apache tribal land. The White Mountain Apache Police Department confirmed the discovery of human remains and is treating the case as a homicide, though they have not disclosed specific details about why they believe Colelay was murdered.
The tragic news has deeply shaken her family and the wider community. Challistia, who was reported missing earlier, was remembered by loved ones as an outgoing, fun-loving, and artistic young woman. According to a GoFundMe page created by her family, she was affectionately called “Tia” or “Baby girl” and was known for her bright smile and teasing nature. Challistia had a passion for painting, drawing, crafting, and enjoying the outdoors, including camping and fishing with family.
SUPPORT THE FAMILY - GOD BLESS YOU
The investigation into her death began after a visit from the Bureau of Investigations of the Fort Apache Indian Reservation, who showed the family evidence, including photos of clothing, shoes, jewelry, and a phone, all of which were confirmed to belong to Colelay. The family was notified of the discovery on November 4.
Darlene Gomez, an attorney and activist for Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Relatives, expressed her heartbreak, emphasizing the need for better police training and protocols to prevent such tragedies. “It breaks my heart because this goes on far too often,” Gomez stated, urging law enforcement to adopt stricter policies when handling cases of missing Indigenous children.
As the investigation continues, Challistia’s family is grappling with the loss of a beloved daughter and sister. A GoFundMe has been set up to help cover funeral expenses, with donations pouring in from those who remember her vibrant spirit and the joy she brought to those around her. Authorities are urging anyone with information related to the case to come forward as they work to bring justice to Colelay and her family.