The small community of Tiffin, Ohio, is left reeling after a horrific murder-suicide took the lives of four individuals—two children and two adults—on the evening of November 19, 2025. What began as a routine afternoon quickly turned into a scene of unspeakable tragedy, forever altering the lives of all who knew the victims and leaving the community in a state of shock.
Around 6:24 p.m., Tiffin police responded to calls of gunshots and screams at a residence on the 100 block of Huss Street. When officers arrived, they found a devastating scene: two children, a 7-year-old and a 7-month-old, along with 29-year-old Dustin Willey, had been killed. The children, full of promise and love, and Dustin, who was there to help a mother in need, were all victims of an unexpected eruption of violence.
SUPPORT THE FAMILY - GOD BLESS YOU
The woman at the center of this tragedy, who has not been publicly named under Marsy’s Law, had been in the process of gathering belongings amid domestic issues when Ryan Eagon, 42, the alleged perpetrator, appeared suddenly in the driveway. Eagon, who was believed to be out of town, then shot and killed his estranged partner’s family before turning the gun on himself.
Remembering the Victims
The 7-Year-Old: A bright, spirited child who had their whole life ahead of them, now remembered for their laughter, kindness, and deep love for their family. Though their time was brief, the impact of their joyful spirit will live on in the hearts of those who knew them.
The 7-Month-Old Infant: A symbol of innocence, sweetness, and new beginnings. In the short time they spent on earth, they brought endless joy to their family, leaving a legacy of love and tenderness.
Dustin Willey: A devoted father and friend, who stepped in to help during a difficult time. His courage and willingness to support his loved ones at great personal risk made him a hero in the eyes of those who knew him. He will be remembered for his compassion and the love he gave freely to those around him.
Ryan Eagon: Although he caused this unimaginable pain, his life is a reminder of the importance of mental health support and intervention. As authorities work to understand the motive behind the violence, Eagon’s actions highlight the need for greater resources to address domestic conflicts before they escalate.
A Mother’s Unimaginable Loss
At the center of this tragedy is the mother of the two children, whose strength in the face of horror remains remarkable. Despite witnessing the deaths of her children and the man who came to help, she summoned the strength to call for help, guiding responders to the scene. Her grief is indescribable, and she will need ongoing support as she navigates the unimaginable loss of her family.
Community Comes Together to Mourn
In the wake of this devastating event, the Tiffin community has come together to mourn the lives lost and offer support to those affected. Tiffin Police Chief David Paul expressed his condolences, acknowledging the widespread impact this tragedy has had on the community—neighbors, first responders, medical staff, and the local school community. Grief support services are being organized to help those struggling with the emotional aftermath.
As investigations continue, the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation and the Seneca County Coroner’s Office are working to provide answers and bring clarity to the circumstances of this tragedy. However, as the community heals, the focus remains on honoring the memory of those lost and providing strength to those left behind.
Forever in Our Hearts
In memory of those taken too soon:
A 7-year-old child whose bright spirit will never fade.
A 7-month-old baby whose innocence and sweetness will be forever cherished.
Dustin Willey, a devoted father, whose bravery in a moment of crisis made a lasting impact.
Though these lives were tragically cut short, their legacy will continue in the stories shared, the love that endures, and the lessons learned from their memory. May their souls rest in peace, and may the Tiffin community find comfort in each other as they navigate this unfathomable loss.